Book review: All the Wind in the World by Samantha Mabry

All the Wind in the World, by Samatha Mabry, Algonquin Young Readers, 273 pages

I love YA novels and try to read a least one a month. I find them refreshing and without the cynicism that populates too many adult novels. Plus I enjoy the pacing, the characters, and the action. Mostly, I enjoy the innocence.

All the Wind in the World,  which was longlisted for the National Book Award for Young People’s Literature and also a 2017 Booklist Editor’s Choice, wasn’t what I expected. There wasn’t much innocence. Most of it was dark, and bleak. At times it was downright depressing.

This was necessary, though, because the story takes place in a dark and bleak future, in a Southwest ravaged by climate change, in a dry and barren desert where windstorms are the norm, along with swarms of bees, the threat of witches and other dangers.

The book is a blend of dystopic fable and magical realism that relies on instances of our past (the working conditions of field hands and slavery, for instance) to predict the future. It isn’t a very cheery picture. In a world where there is little rain and little chance of growing crops, Sarah Jac and her secret boyfriend James (they present themselves as cousins) work the fields on Southwestern ranches, harvesting maguey, which is used to make alcohol; the water shortage has increased the value of alcohol.

Note: maguey is another word for the agave plant, which grows in southwestern environments and is used to make mezcal.

After Sarah Jac accidentally injures a foreman, she and James jump a train and find themselves at the Real Marvelous Ranch, which is rumored to be cursed.

From then on it’s a series of disasters and bad timing, including deaths, rebellions and betrayals that ultimately lead to Sarah Jac’s impending execution (spoiler alert: James saves her, but at a heavy cost).

What makes the book, though, is a carefully rendered balance of magical elements along with descriptions of the rough working conditions of the maguey harvesters, who have little access to fresh food, health care, crappy living conditions and very limited rights. When contrasted with the owner’s family, it presents readers with a thoughtful perspective on labor and income inequality.

All the Wind in the World is a fast and engrossing read filled with action, tender moments and choices. It’s difficult not to fall in love and root for Sarah Jac, though it’s harder to feel the same for James, who often comes across as rote and uncaring. There’s a definite lack of character development on his part, causing some of his actions to feel false and forced.

Still, the magical elements (prophecies, witches, good luck charms, little girls who may or may not be able to control the wind) add a slice of mystery that works well to thicken the plot and add refreshing complexities. Mabry has created a unique and haunting world, where bees and dust are fiercer than man and the land speaks in the voice of the wind.

My biggest complaint? I wanted to see Sarah Jac make choices based on herself and her own needs, not on a boy. Mabry writes us a strong female heroine who depends upon her own smarts yet, in the end, it still comes down to the-boy-saving-the-girl-at-the-last-minute. It’s time to change this old storyline, especially in impressionable YA books.

My rating? 4 stars

6 thoughts on “Book review: All the Wind in the World by Samantha Mabry

    1. I am, Luanne! And it’s a lot more difficult than I expected, trying to keep myself inside the head of a teenage girl without the wisdom and knowledge of my middle-aged self. A lot, lot, lot more difficult. Sometimes I sit in places where teens hang out and just listen to them talk and realized that, holy, holy, I’ve gotten it all wrong. Then I despair. Then I eat organic junk food. Then I make changes and start writing again. P.S. We’re in Tucson, getting our condo together. It was 97 two days ago. I was in heaven but my more partner was wilting, lol. Big hugs to you.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Oh, I hear you. What a job you’ve set for yourself! I thought it sounded like that is what you had in mind: writing YA. I feel a real affinity for that literature because of the “voice.” I have a half a YA novel, but realized I hadn’t prepared the plot the way I needed to, and plot is not my strong suit haha. Haha 97, no biggie ;)! It was so windy here on Friday. I think it’s supposed to be on Monday, too. I hope it isn’t windy near you.


  1. So I am reading your review today after attending a March for Science rally in Tallahassee. What the primary topic? Climate choice, of course. I hope the kids can save us from ourselves. The march and rally was organized totally by university students–bright, earnest, eager university students studying science.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yay, yay, good for you for marching for science! And yes, yes, I have high hopes for the kids of today when it comes to getting out of the mess we’re leaving them. We are lucky to have a smart group of people social savvy enough to harness their energy to work for lasting change. Still, it saddens me what we’ve done to the world. What a legacy, eh?

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Indeed, at least they don’t seem to hold any grudge against us gray-hairs, or maybe only the ones who are rolling back all the advances we made. I am so hoping for a Blue Wave in November!

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s